Chinese shrug at Google

The Financial Times, citing a person familiar with the situation, said the company will soon say that it will close its Chinese search engine.

Google has not formally unveiled any such plans.

Two months since Google said it would no longer agree to abide by Beijing’s censorship rules even if that meant shutting down its Google.cn site, some Chinese internet users and state newspapers are baying for the company to pull out.

The burst of angry Chinese comments suggested that, in spite of the widespread popularity of Google amongst educated Chinese, the government is steering state-run media and websites to lump the company together with other recent disputes with Washington that have stirred nationalist rancour in China.

“Get the hell out,” wrote one user on the website of the nationalist tabloid the Global Times, in remarks echoed by other readers.

“Ha ha, I’m going to buy firecrackers to celebrate!” wrote another, in anticipation of the company confirming its departure from the online search market.

Joseph Cheng, a City University of Hong Kong politics professor, said China’s ruling Communist Party was deploying nationalism to stifle debate about censorship.

“The criticism of cultural exports, or cultural imperialism, is a kind of defence to justify the Chinese authorities’ censorship controls,” said Cheng.

“In dealing with the American government, the Chinese authorities will try to emphasise that this is only a commercial dispute and has nothing to do with Sino-American relations,” he added.

Good riddance?
A Global Times editorial cited online surveys as showing 80 percent of respondents said they could not care less if Google withdrew from China, the world’s largest Internet market with an estimated 384 million users.

The saga was a reminder of the country’s need to develop its own technology and not rely on foreigners, the editorial said.

“This is a high-tech competition, and also a competition to uphold the state’s sovereignty,” the editorial said.

Some bloggers went a step further and accused Google of being in cahoots with US intelligence.

“It is understood that Google is very tight with the CIA,” wrote “Xiaogui” on the popular portal sina.com.cn. “Take this opportunity to leave now, you spies.”

Though Google has remained mum on the progress of talks, the firm’s chief executive said earlier this month that an outcome is expected “soon”.

The Google case has spread beyond censorship and hacking and has become a diplomatic knot in Sino-US relations, already being challenged by spats over Taiwan, Tibet and the value of the Chinese currency.

The US is studying whether it can legally challenge Chinese Internet restrictions, a top US trade official said recently.

A commentary by the official Xinhua news agency accused Google of pushing a political agenda by “groundlessly accusing the Chinese government” of supporting hacker attacks and by trying to export its own culture, values and ideas.

Blow to innovation?
Analysts said if Google withdrew from China, the biggest losers would be its millions of internet users.

With two research and development centres in China, hundreds of sales staff and engineers working on the Google Android platform and other initiatives, analysts said all may come to a halt if Google decides on a pull out.

“This is not a good thing for Chinese netizens because Google has been the leader in innovation in the search engine field,” said Cao Junbo, chief analyst with iResearch, a Beijing-based research firm specialising in technology matters.

Currently, Google offers Google Maps, Gmail and free music downloads to Chinese users, all of which could be in jeopardy if the company walks.

Even Google’s mobile platform Android is not safe, as Google products such as search which are embedded into the platform will stop working if Google withdraws, making the platform less desirable to consumers, analysts said.

Google’s withdrawal will open up China’s $1bn search market to more local firms, Cao said.

The biggest beneficiary will be domestic search leader Baidu Inc, which already has a sophisticated search advertising display system and a robust sales and customer support team.

Others such as Tencent Holdings, China’s most valuable Internet company, may also benefit as the firm runs the country’s largest instant messaging platform that it could tap into to expand its search network.

“The biggest gainers of Google leaving will definitely be the local firms,” Cao said.